1.0 The Body > 1.9 Reproductive System > 1.9.4 Breast

#3462 PTB *s(y)awk BREAST / SUCK / DRINK

This root is quite widespread, and covers a broad semantic range, from BREAST to SUCK to DRINK (any liquid). By a relatively recent extension of meaning, this root is also used for SMOKE (tobacco), and thence for TOBACCO itself (as in Lahu).1

There is a promising Chinese comparandum 欶, Mand. shuò proposed by Coblin (1986:144). In Matisoff 1970 (#57) I suggested that WB sok (also transcribable as sauk) ‘drink, smoke’ and Lahu šú ‘tobacco’ were cognate. I still believe that to be correct, even though in Matisoff 1988:1192 (The Dictionary of Lahu) I entertained an alternative comparison with WB hrup ‘snuff up; sniff; sip; sup’. It now looks as if WB hrup might be related rather to Chinese 呷 (OC *hrap, Mand. xiā) ‘to drink in with a sucking movement’, cited in Coblin 1986:43. This seems preferable semantically and phonologically to Coblin’s comparison of the Chinese form to WB hap ‘bite at’ < PTB *hap [STC #89].

rnanalysislgidreflexglossgfnlanguagegrpidgrpnogrpgeneticcitationsrcabbrsrcidrn
775463462168sr+uksuck / drink*Sino-Tibetan10Sino-Tibetan (previously published reconstructions)0Coblin 86WSC-SH1440
16276534621035sʻuk²breastsMatupi691.2.1.2Southern Plains Chin1Luce 85GHL-PPBP.170
16276934621633soʔ³breastsWomatu691.2.1.2Southern Plains Chin1Luce 85GHL-PPBP.170
16276734621508sʻuk⁴breastsTha'oa711.2.3Maraic1Luce 85GHL-PPBP.170
47050m,34621063cho-sòk-suckv.Mikir [Karbi]141.5Mikir [Karbi]1Grüssner 79 BPKHG-MikirQ730
1450603462581sokbreast; man's nippleGaro (Bangladesh)811.7.1.2Garo1Burling 92 GaBaRB-GB0
1450613462,3463,298581sok-bit-chibreast milk; mother's milkGaro (Bangladesh)811.7.1.2Garo1Burling 92 GaBaRB-GB0
1450623462,m,1352581sok-kit-tinippleGaro (Bangladesh)811.7.1.2Garo1Burling 92 GaBaRB-GB0
24031934621188jokdrinkvNocte841.7.2.1Tangsa-Nocte1Marrison 67 NagaGEM-CNL0
1642753462,1019566sɔʔ⁴ʃi¹breastsGanan401.7.3.2Asakian1Luce 85GHL-PPBL.1460
1642763462,1019720sôk³ʃi³breastsKadu (Kantu)401.7.3.2Asakian1Luce 85GHL-PPBL.1460
164274p,34621355ă◦suʔ²breastsSak (Dodem)401.7.3.2Asakian1Luce 85GHL-PPBL.1460
1282373462,m378thruk◦canurse / sucklevBunan202.1.1Western Himalayish0Sharma, S.R. 91 BuSBN-BunQ5.4.60
510603462327soNdrink in a gulpBantawa762.3.2Southern Kiranti1Rai 85 BnDsNKR-Bant0
641693462,m449syuŋʔ-sasuckChepang282.4Kham-Magar-Chepang1Caughley 72 CVocSIL-Chep6.B.2.20
130132p,p,3462616ka◦mə◦scçoksuckvrGyalrong (Eastern)783.3.1rGyalrong1Sun H 91 rEQSHK-rGEQ5.4.50
386223462201suʔ⁵⁵drinkAchang (Lianghe)446.1.1Burmish1Dai 85 AcJZJZ-Achang0
384873462204ʂoʔ⁵⁵drinkAchang (Longchuan)446.1.1Burmish1Dai 85 AcJZJZ-Achang0
41361334621824ʂoʔ⁵⁵drinkv.Achang (Longchuan)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.280
2072133462200ʂoʔ⁵⁵drinkAchang (Longchuan)446.1.1Burmish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC534.410
387603462207suʔ⁵⁵drinkAchang (Luxi)446.1.1Burmish1Dai 85 AcJZJZ-Achang0
175443462209ʂuʔ⁵⁵drinkAchang (Xiandao)446.1.1Burmish1Dai 89 XianDQ-Xiandao18950
41361434621825ʂuʔ⁵⁵drinkv.Achang (Xiandao)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.290
132913462370ʃauʔ⁵⁵drinkBola446.1.1Burmish1Dai 89 BolaDQ-Bola18950
41361734621829ʃauʔ⁵⁵drinkv.Bola (Luxi)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.320
41361234621823tθɑuʔ⁴drinkv.Burmese (Rangoon)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.270
20723834621428tθɑuʔ⁴⁴drinkBurmese (Spoken Rangoon)446.1.1Burmish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC534.400
3038833462409saukdrinkBurmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Benedict 72 STCSTC76n2320
2403373462392sokdrinkvBurmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Marrison 67 NagaGEM-CNL0
1649243462393sokdrink / suck inv.Burmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Luce 85GHL-PPBY.580
4374793462406sokdrink, smokev.Burmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Benedict 76 WBurPKB-WBRD0
764353462410sokdrinkBurmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Coblin 86WSC-SH1440
2072123462411thɔkdrinkBurmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC534.390
41361134621822tθɔk⁴drinkv.Burmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.260
437480p,3462406ə-sok-drink, smokev.Burmese (Written)446.1.1Burmish1Benedict 76 WBurPKB-WBRD0
2337663462653ʃòʔdrinkHpun (Northern)446.1.1Burmish1Henderson 86 HpunEJAH-Hpun0
41361634621828ʃauk⁵⁵drinkv.Langsu (Luxi)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.310
154923462886ʃu:k⁵⁵drinkv.Lashi446.1.1Burmish1Dai 89 LashDQ-Lashi3.7.70
41361834621830ʃuːk⁵⁵drinkv.Leqi (Luxi)446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.330
45271534621965θɔʔdrinkMarma446.1.1Burmish1Huziwara 08 SakHK-Sak860
1523834621024ʃauk⁵⁵drinkv.Maru [Langsu]446.1.1Burmish1Dai 89 LangDQ-Langsu3.7.70
20721434621034ʃauk⁵⁵drinkMaru [Langsu]446.1.1Burmish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC534.430
4411134621686ʃuʔ⁵⁵drinkAtsi [Zaiwa]446.1.1Burmish1Xu 84 ZaiwaJZ-Zaiwa0
41361534621827ʃuʔ⁵⁵drinkv.Atsi [Zaiwa]446.1.1Burmish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.300
20723934621693ʃuʔ⁵⁵drinkAtsi [Zaiwa]446.1.1Burmish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC534.420
113773462152C-ʃukᴸ|tobacco*Loloish456.1.2Loloish1Bradley 79 PLoDB-PLolo406B0
20721534621215ɕhu̱⁵⁵drinkNusu (Bijiang)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC534.450
4242134621220ɕu³¹drinkNusu (Southern)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Sun J 86 NusuJZ-Nusu0
1610734621218ɕu̱³¹drinkNusu (Central/Zhizhiluo)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Dai 89 NusADQ-NusuA1895.0
4270334621217ɕʰu̱⁵⁵drinkNusu (Central)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Sun J 86 NusuJZ-Nusu0
1635434621216ʂu̱⁵³drinkNusu (Central)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Dai 89 NusBDQ-NusuB1895.0
41361934621831ʂu̱⁵³drinkv.Nusu (Central)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Huang and Dai 92 TBLTBL1370.340
4256134621219ʂu̱⁵⁵drinkNusu (Northern)466.1.2.1Northern Loloish1Sun J 86 NusuJZ-Nusu0
3114053462831šútobaccoLahu (Black)476.1.2.2Central Loloish1Matisoff 88 DLJAM-DL11920
1910423462851su³⁵tobaccoLahu (Black)476.1.2.2Central Loloish1Sun H 91 ZMYYZMYYC217.330
3021413462856su⁴tobaccoLahu (Yellow)476.1.2.2Central Loloish1Chang 86JZ-Lahu0
31140634621770shuˆsniff up (as salt water for runny nose)Akha486.1.2.3Southern Loloish1Lewis 68 AEDcPL-AED0
3114073462228sjuqsniff; smell; suckAkha486.1.2.3Southern Loloish1Hansson 89 AHKPILH-PL0
775473462478sruksuck / drinkChinese (Old)539.0.1Old Chinese0Coblin 86WSC-SH1440
775483462468ṣåksuck, inhaleChinese (Middle)549.0.2Middle Chinese0Coblin 86WSC-SH1440

Chinese comparanda

欶 OC *sŭk, GSR #1222o ‘suck’; Li 1971: *sruk; Baxter 1992: *srok; Mand. shuò.

Gong 1995 #279 reconstructed *rsuk. In Li’s system another possibility is *sthruk, by analogy with 束 ‘bundle’, Mand. shù which is reconstructed *sthjuk to account for the presence in this series of 誎 / 促 ‘urge on’, Mand. *tshjuk. Schuessler 1987:567 reconstructed 束 shù ‘bundle’ as *?‑juk to indicate that the initial is uncertain, and in 2007:473 suggests a pre-Old Chinese form *C‑sok.

This comparison is made in Coblin 1986:144.

The vowel correspondence is problematic. OC *‑uk (Li)/*‑ok (Baxter) normally corresponds to PTB *‑uk, as in 曲 ‘bend/crooked’, PTB *guk~*kuk, OC *khjuk (Li)/*kh(r)jok (Baxter), Mand qū, qǔ.
[ZJH]

呷 OC *χap (not in GSR #629), ‘to drink with a sucking movement’; Li 1971: *hrap; Baxter 1992: *xrap; Mand. xiā.

The Middle Chinese vocalism dictates an Old Chinese reconstruction with medial *‑r‑, but Schuessler 2007:526 has *hap, arguing that the MC vocalism may be due to “sound symbolism or archaistic colloquialism”. This enables him to make a comparison with PTB *hap [STC #89] as well as with Austroasiatic forms of similar shape.

Matisoff’s proposal that 呷 xiā is instead cognate to WB hrup ‘snuff up; sniff; sip; sup’ provides a better match for Chinese *‑r‑, but the vocalism is problematic. We would expect a Burmese cognate in ‑ap < PTB *‑ap. Of course, given the likelihood of sound symbolism in words with these semantics, irregular correspondences are to be expected. It is therefore not an easy matter to decide if Chinese 呷 xiā is better compared to PTB *hap or WB hrup, or if the similarity of phonological shape is not due to cognacy at all.
[ZJH]


^ 1.
The extension of ‘drink/suck’ to ‘smoke (tobacco)’ is common in the world’s languages. Cf. e.g. Japanese nomu ‘drink’, tabako wo nomu ‘smoke a cigarette’.